Neville W. Cramer: “A New Comprehensive Immigration Reform.”


Neville W. Cramer, United States Department of Justice, Immigration and Naturalization Service, Special Agent-in-Charge (Retired), Port St. Lucie, Florida.


Prior to granting the illegal immigrants any type of legal status, we first need to revamp the way we deploy our current Customs and Border Protection resources.

The borders must be secured using technology such as drones, sensors, night vision, ground radar systems and even satellites.  Human intelligence gathering must also be significantly increased. We are also in dire need of several large detention facilities on or near our Southwest border to house apprehended illegal immigrants for periods of up to one year.

More Border Patrol Agents will help in some areas. However, as we have seen over the last half-century, increasing manpower for the sake of making “political points” makes the U.S. Border Patrol a bigger agency, but does little to truly secure our borders.

In the recent debates, very little is being mentioned about the most effective method we could use to curtail illegal immigration – mandatory utilization of E-Verify – the system that advises employers if their employees have the legal right to work in the United States.

I suggest that anyone who is interested in truly curtailing illegal immigration, read the Executive Summary of the 1993 report of the bi-partisan Commission on Immigration Reform. Readers will realize that E-Verify is the most effective way to bring about humanitarian change to our immigration enforcement programs, significantly reduce the influx of illegal immigrants (no matter how they arrived) and prevent the need for future amnesties.

Speaking of “amnesty,” to achieve “comprehensive immigration reform” there is no need to grant “a path to U.S. Citizenship” to any of the estimated eleven million illegal aliens currently living here.

In an attempt to be “humanitarian,” our representatives in Washington are failing to tell their constituents about the resulting chain migration that will descend upon us. If we offer eventual U.S. Citizenship to this group, it will likely lead to a legal influx of more than fifty million or more new “immediate relative immigrants” over the next fifteen years.

The U.S. cannot survive this type of mass migration without serious damage to our public education system, health care programs and general infrastructure.  In short, a “path to U.S. Citizenship” will lead to the demise of the United States as we know it today.

As I have advocated numerous times to groups across America, (and written in my book “Immigration Chaos” in 2007), the maximum benefit we should offer to most of our illegal alien population is something similar to a renewable “non-immigrant worker” visa – and that’s all! The claim that this will create some sort of “second class” person is absolute nonsense. There are currently hundreds of thousands of legal “non-immigrants” currently living in the U.S. and most are quite happy to be here.

As opposed to many other growing problems in the U.S., successful immigration reform is truly quite achievable.

However, instead of focusing on another failed amnesty, America first needs to get operational control of our physical borders.

In addition there must be a federal mandate for all employers to use E-Verify, accompanied by an effective and punitive employer sanctions program. Without these critical components, we will never curtail illegal immigration, and the current attempt at immigration reform will simply be another useless attempt by Congress and the White House to end our immigration chaos.




Neville W. Cramer served more than twenty-six years as a law enforcement officer with the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS). At the time of his retirement in late 2002, he was one of the most experienced INS Special Agents in the U.S. Department of Justice.

After serving four years as a police officer in Arizona and Florida, he began his immigration law enforcement career in 1976, as a U.S. Border Patrol Agent in Eagle Pass, Texas. After his tour of duty on the U.S.-Mexican border, Cramer held the following positions at INS;

  • 1977-1984 Special Agent and Supervisory Special Agent in Chicago, Illinois and Washington D.C.
  • 1984-1986 Senior Special Agent, Office of Enforcement, INS Headquarters, Washington, D.C.
  • 1986-1990 Deputy Assistant Commissioner, Enforcement Division, INS Headquarters Washington, D.C.,
  • 1990-1996 Director, Immigration Officer Academy, Federal Law Enforcement Training Center  (FLETC) Glynco, Georgia.
  • Special Agent-in-Charge, Overseas Enforcement, INS Headquarters, Washington, D.C. (1996-2002)

During his tenure as Deputy Assistant Commissioner, he was responsible for the development and implementation of the first INS status verification system, now known as E-Verify.

After his retirement from the INS in 2002, Mr. Cramer began his own successful consulting firm. Many of his contracts with the Antiterrorism Assistance Administration (ATA) required training in more than fifteen countries, including Algiers, Yemen, Jordan, Colombia and Tajikistan.

In 2012, Cramer was selected by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the Government of the United Arab Emirates to serve as an immigration enforcement expert. After serving almost three years in the Emirates, he returned to the U.S. and relocated to Port St. Lucie, Florida in 2017.

In addition to being an active proponent of effective U.S. immigration reform, Neville Cramer has authored two books, including his latest Immigration Chaos – Solutions to an American Crisis (2007). He has been featured on several local and national television and radio programs. He has a Bachelors Degree in Law Enforcement Administration from the University of Arizona and a Masters Degree in Criminal Justice from the George Washington, University, Washington, D.C. He was also the first INS Special Agent to attend the prestigious FBI National Academy (157th Session).


3 thoughts on “Neville W. Cramer: “A New Comprehensive Immigration Reform.”

  1. How sad to think that these knowledgeable, no nonsense practices weren’t put in place 10 years ago. Think of the millions of illegals living here since then and the billions of dollars spent on healthcare, education, incarcerations and welfare programs to support them, to say nothing of the numbers of deaths at the hands of criminal illegals. It’s no wonder Donald Trump was elected and in large part due to his ‘build a wall’ promise. Naturally, I see ‘the wall’ as part physical barrier and part technical support as Mr. Cramer points out. But symbolically, it represented a new perspective on illegal immigration to millions of voters.
    It was only a few years ago that we saw the pictures of Mexican trains carrying thousands of immigrants from countries to Mexico’s south and we had no place to house all of the unemployable women and children and young men posing as teenagers. How many are still in this country and where are they? We are now 10 years further into this horrendous morass that gets worse by the day and suggesting it needs fixing means being called a racist, hateful deplorable. How long can America sustain the cost – both in treasure and blood?

Leave a Reply